Alessandro Stesi
Corporate backup solutions Self-protection tests
Introduction
Corporate backup solutions: In light of the growing number of ransomware attacks in which cryptolockers stop database processes to unlock database files for encryption (Cerber, GlobeImposter, Rapid, Serpent) and they can encrypt local and network backups to request a ransom payment (Rapid, Spora), we decided to test the self-protection capabilities of the best backup solutions used in the corporate environments available for testing.
The test aims to check the sustainability of the processes and services of the products against the typical attacks on the security software described below, as well as the self-protection of the local backup and of the product files. Ransomware can encrypt configuration files and local backup files that belong to a backup program by disabling file recovery. In addition, once access to the agent or server processes is obtained, the attacker can delete backup copies of files not only locally, but also in the cloud on behalf of a backup solution.
This document is a summary of the enterprise backup solutions test report and includes a description of the test environment, a list of tested solutions and their versions, an overview of test scenarios, as well as results and conclusions based on these results. We do not classify the tested solutions and do not award any prize, but we provide the results “as is” for informational purposes only.
Testing environment
The tests were conducted on the virtual machines of:
– Windows 8.1 SP1 32 bit build 9600
– Windows 10 Enterprise 64 bit Build 16299
– Windows Server 2012 R2 Standard 64 bit v. 6.3.9600 Build 9600
We have tested backup solutions on platforms
32 and 64 bit because the process injection techniques used in the test scenarios differ on these platforms. In addition, 32 and 64 bit product builds may contain a different set of features, including self-protection, and their implementation may depend on the architecture of the operating system.
Tested products
Corporate backup solutions: The most recent versions of the following products available at the time of testing were tested:
|
Product name |
Components |
Version |
|
Management Server Agent |
12.5 9010 12.5 9010 |
|
|
Unified Data Protection Server Unified Data Protection Client |
6.5.4175 Aggiornamento 2 Build 667 6.5.4175.791 v.r6.5 |
|
|
Backup & Replication Agent for Microsoft Windows |
9.5 Aggiornamento 3 2.1.0.423 |
|
|
Veritas Backup Exec |
Server Agent Utility pour Windows |
16.0 Rev. 1142 16.0 Rev. 1142-1632
|
Each product was installed with the default settings and updated before running the test.
Corporate backup solutions – Test scenarios
The test suite includes 31 tests that simulate attacks on local backup files, product files, processes, services and cloud storage that aim to block the backup and restore service. The “Product File Protection” test category contains simple tests aimed at destroying backup and application files making it impossible to recover data encrypted by ransomware.
The second group of tests “Protection of processes and products services” is essential for self-protection since the malware can inject the malicious code into a backup agent and act on behalf of a backup solution obtaining all the necessary privileges to check the backup files. At the behest of an attacker, a malicious process can interrupt processes and services with consequent blocking of the backup and restore application
or deleting backup files on behalf of a backup solution. The latest series of tests is “Cloud backup and recovery protection” and is addressed to communication interfaces with cloud storage. The attack of DNS poisoning or the improper use of the CLI can cause the cloud backup service to be interrupted.
Corporate backup solutions – Conclusions
The purpose of the test was to verify the backup software’s self-protection capabilities to protect related files, processes, services and cloud storage from scenarios that can potentially be run by ransomware.
The results showed that most of the tested products are not ready in many cases to counter ransomware-type attacks by allowing a potential attacker to block user backups and disable backup and restore services. Only Acronis Backup has shown good results with an 87% and 81% effectiveness rate for 32-bit and 64-bit products, similarly providing complete self-protection and service sustainability features.
Download the complete department here: Nio Guard Independent Study_IT
[btnsx id=”2931″]
Related articles:
Modern Data Protection: The Difference is in the Cloud
BaaS | Cloud Backup | Backup as a Service
[Name change] Acronis Data Cloud –> Acronis Cyber Cloud
Stay in control of your fast-moving, quick-shifting data
A Hybrid Cloud Backup Solution for System Integrator and reseller
Share
RSS
More Articles…
- From Secure Online Desktop to Cyberfero: rebranding of the leading cybersecurity company
- NIS: what it is and how it protects cybersecurity
- Advanced persistent threats (APTs): what they are and how to defend yourself
- Penetration Testing and MFA: A Dual Strategy to Maximize Security
- Penetration Testing: Where to Strike to Protect Your IT Network
- Ransomware: a plague that brings companies and institutions to their knees. Should you pay the ransom? Here is the answer.
- Why IT audit and log management are important for Cybersecurity
- Red Team, Blue Team and Purple Team: what are the differences?
Categories …
- Backup as a Service (18)
- Acronis Cloud Backup (11)
- Veeam Cloud Connect (4)
- Cloud Conference (3)
- Cloud CRM (1)
- Cloud Server/VPS (22)
- Conferenza Cloud (4)
- Cyberfero (15)
- ICT Monitoring (5)
- Log Management (2)
- News (25)
- ownCloud (4)
- Privacy (7)
- Security (203)
- Cyber Threat Intelligence (CTI) (8)
- Deception (4)
- Ethical Phishing (11)
- Netwrix Auditor (2)
- Penetration Test (11)
- Posture Guard (3)
- SOCaaS (65)
- Vulnerabilities (84)
- Web Hosting (15)
Tags
Unknown Feed
Full Disclosure
- SQL Injection in Admin Functionality - dolphin.prov7.4.2 March 25, 2025Posted by Andrey Stoykov on Mar 24# Exploit Title: SQL Injection in Admin Functionality - dolphin.prov7.4.2 # Date: 03/2025 # Exploit Author: Andrey Stoykov # Version: 7.4.2 # Date: 03/2025 # Tested on: Debian 12 # Blog: https://msecureltd.blogspot.com/2025/03/friday-fun-pentest-series-21-sql.html SQL Injection in Admin Functionality: Steps to Reproduce: 1. Login as admin user and visit the page […]
- Stored XSS via Send Message Functionality - dolphin.prov7.4.2 March 25, 2025Posted by Andrey Stoykov on Mar 24# Exploit Title: Stored XSS via Send Message Functionality - dolphin.prov7.4.2 # Date: 03/2025 # Exploit Author: Andrey Stoykov # Version: 7.4.2 # Date: 03/2025 # Tested on: Debian 12 # Blog: https://msecureltd.blogspot.com/2025/03/friday-fun-pentest-series-20-stored-xss.html Stored XSS via Send Message Functionality: Steps to Reproduce: 1. Login and visit "http://192.168.58.170/dolphinCMS/mail.php?mode=compose" 2. Add...
- APPLE-SA-03-11-2025-4 visionOS 2.3.2 March 20, 2025Posted by Apple Product Security via Fulldisclosure on Mar 20APPLE-SA-03-11-2025-4 visionOS 2.3.2 visionOS 2.3.2 addresses the following issues. Information about the security content is also available at https://support.apple.com/122284. Apple maintains a Security Releases page at https://support.apple.com/100100 which lists recent software updates with security advisories. WebKit Available for: Apple Vision Pro Impact: Maliciously crafted web content […]
- APPLE-SA-03-11-2025-3 macOS Sequoia 15.3.2 March 20, 2025Posted by Apple Product Security via Fulldisclosure on Mar 20APPLE-SA-03-11-2025-3 macOS Sequoia 15.3.2 macOS Sequoia 15.3.2 addresses the following issues. Information about the security content is also available at https://support.apple.com/122283. Apple maintains a Security Releases page at https://support.apple.com/100100 which lists recent software updates with security advisories. WebKit Available for: macOS Sequoia Impact: Maliciously crafted web […]
- APPLE-SA-03-11-2025-2 iOS 18.3.2 and iPadOS 18.3.2 March 20, 2025Posted by Apple Product Security via Fulldisclosure on Mar 20APPLE-SA-03-11-2025-2 iOS 18.3.2 and iPadOS 18.3.2 iOS 18.3.2 and iPadOS 18.3.2 addresses the following issues. Information about the security content is also available at https://support.apple.com/122281. Apple maintains a Security Releases page at https://support.apple.com/100100 which lists recent software updates with security advisories. WebKit Available for: iPhone XS […]
- APPLE-SA-03-11-2025-1 Safari 18.3.1 March 20, 2025Posted by Apple Product Security via Fulldisclosure on Mar 20APPLE-SA-03-11-2025-1 Safari 18.3.1 Safari 18.3.1 addresses the following issues. Information about the security content is also available at https://support.apple.com/122285. Apple maintains a Security Releases page at https://support.apple.com/100100 which lists recent software updates with security advisories. WebKit Available for: macOS Ventura and macOS Sonoma Impact: Maliciously crafted […]
- CVE-2019-16261 (UPDATE): Unauthenticated POST requests to Tripp Lite UPS Systems March 20, 2025Posted by Lucas Lalumière on Mar 20[Author]: Lucas Lalumiere [Contact]: lucas.lalum () gmail com [Date]: 2025-3-17 [Vendor]: Tripp Lite [Product]: SU750XL UPS [Firmware]: 12.04.0052 [CVE Reference]: CVE-2019-16261 ============================ Affected Products (Tested): ============================ - Tripp Lite PDU's (e.g., PDUMH15AT) - Tripp Lite UPS's (e.g., SU750XL) *NEW* ====================== Vulnerability Summary: ====================== CVE-2019-16261 describes...
- Multiple sandbox escapes in asteval python sandboxing module March 11, 2025Posted by areca-palm via Fulldisclosure on Mar 11[CVE pending] Sandboxing Python is notoriously difficult, the Python module "asteval" is no exception. Add to this the fact that a large set of numpy functions are exposed within the sandbox by default. Versions
- SEC Consult SA-20250226-0 :: Multiple vulnerabilities in Siemens A8000 CP-8050 & CP-8031 PLC February 27, 2025Posted by SEC Consult Vulnerability Lab via Fulldisclosure on Feb 27SEC Consult Vulnerability Lab Security Advisory < 20250226-0 > ======================================================================= title: Multiple Vulnerabilities product: Siemens A8000 CP-8050 PLC Siemens A8000 CP-8031 PLC vulnerable version:
- Re: MitM attack against OpenSSH's VerifyHostKeyDNS-enabled client February 27, 2025Posted by Jordy Zomer on Feb 27Hey all, First of all, cool findings! I've been working on the CodeQL query and have a revised version that I think improves accuracy and might offer some performance gains (though I haven't done rigorous benchmarking). The key change is the use of `StackVariableReachability` and making sure that there's […]
Customers
Twitter FEED
Recent activity
-
SecureOnlineDesktop
Estimated reading time: 6 minutes L'impatto crescente delle minacce informatiche, su sistemi operativi privati op… https://t.co/FimxTS4o9G
-
SecureOnlineDesktop
Estimated reading time: 6 minutes The growing impact of cyber threats, on private or corporate operating systems… https://t.co/y6G6RYA9n1
-
SecureOnlineDesktop
Tempo di lettura stimato: 6 minuti Today we are talking about the CTI update of our services. Data security is… https://t.co/YAZkn7iFqa
-
SecureOnlineDesktop
Estimated reading time: 6 minutes Il tema della sicurezza delle informazioni è di grande attualità in questo peri… https://t.co/tfve5Kzr09
-
SecureOnlineDesktop
Estimated reading time: 6 minutes The issue of information security is very topical in this historical period ch… https://t.co/TP8gvdRcrF
Newsletter
{subscription_form_1}Products and Solutions
Partners
Cloud Models
News
- From Secure Online Desktop to Cyberfero: rebranding of the leading cybersecurity company May 6, 2024
- NIS: what it is and how it protects cybersecurity April 22, 2024
- Advanced persistent threats (APTs): what they are and how to defend yourself April 17, 2024
- Penetration Testing and MFA: A Dual Strategy to Maximize Security April 15, 2024
- Penetration Testing: Where to Strike to Protect Your IT Network March 25, 2024
Google Reviews
Ottima azienda, servizi molto utili, staff qualificato e competente. Raccomandata!read more
Ottimo supportoread more
E' un piacere poter collaborare con realtà di questo tiporead more
Un ottimo fornitore.
Io personalmente ho parlato con l' Ing. Venuti, valore aggiunto indubbiamente.read more
About
© 2024 Cyberfero s.r.l. All Rights Reserved. Sede Legale: via Statuto 3 - 42121 Reggio Emilia (RE) – PEC [email protected] Cod. fiscale e P.IVA 03058120357 – R.E.A. 356650 Informativa Privacy - Certificazioni ISO